Castalia, Ohio is one of those little one horse towns comprised of suburban family homes which would work if Sandusky was actually a big city. But mostly its a farming community so there really isn’t much there but a pizza place, an ice cream parlor, a gas station and Cold Creek Cafe, a tiny diner in an old building on Castalia’s “Main St”. The food is ok and very typical of a midwestern diner. The decor, meh…

Rueben with Fried Mushrooms

Onion Rings

Perch Sandwich with Onion Rings

Pancakes and Eggs